Diskussion:Tellursäure

Schwaefelsaeure

A comparison with sulfuric acid is misleading, because sulfuric acid and telluric acid are, althought he naming gives a different impression, not comparible at all. Sulfuric acid contains two double bounded oxygen atoms, which makes it obvious that the molecule is more acidic then telluric acid, which only has six hydroxy groups. Comparing the two, gives the impression this is solely caused by the different atom (since the atomic configuration is not given as a context) and this already lead in the nl: article to larger misunderstandings (ie, claims that the two are similar acids in configuration etc). If you must compare, then better compare with a similar molecule such as S(OH)6 (although I don't think it exists)... Or, if you want a strong acid after all, use something that does not seem to claim a fair comparison, and use HCl or something. Maletwasanderes 11:46, 25. Jun. 2009 (CEST)

You are right. The purpose of the comparison is to show that they cannot be compared. So, what we have to do is to explain the difference. Gruß --FK1954 17:54, 25. Jun. 2009 (CEST)

Better now? Gruß --FK1954 18:01, 25. Jun. 2009 (CEST)

Hmm, but what is the intention of the comparison in the first place? I see little added value to be honest. The same could be explained for any random acid :) The wrong suggestion that was there before has been removed though. Thanks for that :) Maletwasanderes 19:41, 25. Jun. 2009 (CEST)

I guess the intention was just to show that there is a difference in acidity between sulfuric and telluric acid. An explanation why there is a difference should have been added. Yeah, there's a lot of work to do... Gruß --FK1954 20:49, 25. Jun. 2009 (CEST)